Here’s the list of the other contributors:
Kevin Trenberth, NCAR
Andrew Watson, University of East Anglia
Roger Pielke, Jr., University of Colorado
Kerry Emanuel, MIT
Judith Curry, Georgia Tech
Laurens Bouwer, Vrije University
Gabriele Hegerl, University of Edinburgh
You can be your own judge, but two things seem clear. First, each contribution was interesting in its own right. Second, the whole was greater than the sum of the parts. The different viewpoints had the feel of an ensemble forecast (a juxtaposition of a number of forecasts, each starting from different, but plausible initial states) of weather. And like that ensemble forecast, this range of opinions and rationales gives even a layperson a better feel for where experts agree, and where issues are in debate. Kudos to Yale Environment 360 for providing material like this!
Want extra credit? Post your own views, either here or on one of these sites.